Colóquio

What is a physical entity?

Faculdade de Letras da ULisboa

For understanding Nature, modern science has turned to mathematical and physical models that dramatically simplified the complexity of natural phenomena and processes. This was the very key for its long-lasting success. Nevertheless, as Husserl wrote regarding Galileo, this move was simultaneously a discovering and a concealing one. In a sense, the modern understanding of Nature was caught in mathematical formulae. Galileo's geometrization of Physics, and then the grow of analytical and linear methods in mathematical techniques, set the stage where Nature should be addressed from now on: a realm of idealized material essences, like mass points, perfect trajectories, exact positions, and so on, suitable for mathematical formalisms. However, the development of this realm was more and more oblivious of the original sense of Nature, and of the pieces of creative thinking that originally instituted all these idealized essences where modern Physics found out its objects. Locked-up in a realm consisting of material and formal essences, developing a more and more blind manipulation of symbols in formulae and calculations, Physics could now dream of an exact Nature as the simple correlate of this mathematical science of Nature. As a result, at least since the scientific revolution of the 17th century till the beginning of the last century, Physics will assume the perfect absolute localization in time and space, the identity, and the separability of all physical systems. 

Now, at the beginning of our century, a kind of counter-reaction is emerging, due to the severe changes that the 20th century brought to classical Physics. What was really new in the science of Nature in the last century was but forth by Quantum Physics. It is no longer a classical theory, while Relativity continues to be to a certain extent classical, and can be viewed as the cul­mi­nat­ing point of Mechanics (reframing Newton’s gravitation law) and Electromag­netism (with­out the ether-hypothesis). Classical Me­chanics, Relati­vity and Electromagnetism conveyed a clear and unambiguous ontology, respectively centered on the concepts of mass, distributed over space and time, of field, as an extended, non-punc­tual reality, and of space-time “curvature”, in its interactions with the stress-energy ten­sor. The mathematical formalisms they developed prompted by themselves, as their correlates, a clear con­ception of what the (exact) physical reality should be in and by itself.

The other way around, Quantum Mechanics developed a mathematical formalism which was largely undecided about the very nature of the en­tities to which it referred. This problem plagued Quantum Mechanics since its very beginnings, and still continues today. In addition, there are many other difficult aspects of Quantum Physics regarding both the depiction of the physical reality, and what should be accounted for as “physical”. Thus, concern­ing Quan­tum Mechanics, we are not in a somewhat Kantian situation. We have not a full-fledged, uncontroversial “fact of science” with its fixed ontology. In its place, we have an accurate mathematical formalism (perhaps, the most accurate science has ever created), and a problem regarding its ontological inter­pretation in order to characterize what is “physical”. The modern philosophy of Nature was written in math­ematical for­mulae; now, with Quantum Physics, the mathematical formalism only prom­ises a phi­­losophy of Nature.

Quantum Mechanics is, thus, the opportunity to return to a renewed debate about Nature itself. By virtue of its baffling results, the classical constraints have felt-down. Every new approach to understand Reality must assume that physical beings are complex and have both properties of localization and non-localization, that physical entities share a certain degree of individuality and, at the same time, some degree of non-separability, and also that determinism and indeterminism are only extreme ideal boundaries in between of which physical beings generate and evolve.

So, the colloquium will be led by a twofold interest. On the one hand, in a kind of retrospective, historical reflection, it will try to shed light on the original insights that constituted modern Physics. On the other hand, looking forward, it will address the problems a new understanding of Nature imposes on us in the quantum, post-classical age of Physics.

So, we will question:

  • What has phýsis become in light of Quantum Physics?
  • What was phýsis for the Physics of modernity?
  • How do these accounts of phýsis relate to the sense of Nature that opens the field in which, afterwards, the physicist enters as a methodical researcher?

We invite papers on any topic or question related to these issues. Submissions should be in the form of an extended abstract of no more than 1000 words, anonymized for blind review. Abstracts should be submitted by Sunday 31st July 2017, to colloquium.philosophyphysics@gmail.com.

Scientific board: José Croca | Pedro Alves | Rui Moreira

CFCUL - Centro de Filosofia das Ciências da Universidade de Lisboa / CFUL - Centro de Filosofia da Universidade de Lisboa (Linha de Pensamento Fenomenológico)
CFCUL
Título/data/local do evento

No Dia Nacional dos Cientistas, o conhecimento não risca fronteiras.

O Museu Nacional de História Natural e da Ciência da Universidade de Lisboa celebra a Noite Europeia dos Museus (17 de maio) e o Dia Internacional dos Museus (18 de maio). Nestes dias, os Museus abrem as portas e convidam os cidadãos a conhecer os seus acervos, coleções, exposições e atividades.

Seminário do Centro de Física Teórica e Computacional, por João Amaral (Department of Physics and CICECO, University of Aveiro, Portugal).

Bodião-limpador "em ação"

Seminário Doutoral II (Doutoramento em Biologia), por Beatriz Palinhos Pereira.

Seminário de Lógica Matemática, por Joaquim Waddington (UERJ/UCL).

Seminário de Análise e Equações Diferenciais, por Wladimir Neves (Universidade Federal do Rio de Janeiro).

Título/data/local do evento, logótipos das entidades organizadoras e fotografia de peixe

The event aims to facilitate the exchange of information and knowledge among professionals to advance the understanding, collaboration and capabilities of aquaculture to respond to the impact of climate change in a rapidly changing global environment.

Composição do logótipo da ULisboa e de representação do rosto humano à base de relógios

22 de maio - dois dos doze finalistas da competição são alunos de CIÊNCIAS.

Seminário de Análise e Equações Diferenciais, por Itamar Oliveira (University of Birmingham).

Pintura abstrata azul e rosa

Seminário de Análise e Equações Diferenciais, por Leonid Berlyand (Penn State University).

Technovation Girls Challenge Portugal - Final

Ciências ULisboa recebe 400 participantes para o evento final do Technovation Girls Challenge Portugal.

Seminário do Instituto de Astrofísica e Ciências do Espaço, por Pier-Stefano Corasaniti (Observatoire de Paris-Meudon, France).

Um programa estruturado que combina discussões em grupo, exploração de carreira e workshops informativos, com inscrições até 23 de maio.

Seminário no âmbito do Doutoramento em Biologia e Ecologia das Alterações Globais, por Pierina Jocelyn Mendoza Yengle.

Logótipo do EVM 2025

Candidaturas até 28 de maio.

Uma oportunidade para fortalecer a cultura de segurança e bem-estar em CIÊNCIAS.

Uma oportunidade única para interagir com a comunidade global de computação científica.

Logótipo Moodle

Ação de formação para docentes e investigadores de CIÊNCIAS.

Título/data/local do evento e iconografia representativa de energias renováveis

Inscrições até 16 de maio! Junta-te a esta revolução energética e faz a diferença!

Logótipo Mentimeter

Ação de formação para docentes e investigadores de CIÊNCIAS.

Luís Saraiva (Ciências ULisboa) é o coordenador nacional do evento.

Neste curso ficarás a saber como te podes tornar um permacultor eficiente, produtivo e consciente! O curso está preparado para iniciantes na prática de permacultura.

Formação - Cultivar em Permacultura.

Pessoas a interagirem em frente a um computador portátil

As inscrições para a edição de 2025 da formação decorrem até às 17h do dia 23 de maio.

Páginas