Reasoning Seminar

McTaggart’s Paradox: Obscure or Misunderstood?

Faculdade de Letras da ULisboa
Cartaz do evento

Por Rögnvaldur Ingthorsson (University of Helsinki, Finland).

McTaggart’s argument for the unreality of time is a centrepiece of 20th century philosophy of time, for better or for worse. His analysis of temporal characteristics in terms of the so-called A and B series came to be used as the standard way to characterise the difference between what we today know as the A- vs. B-theory of time, and as the basis of modern tense logic. Furthermore, McTaggart formulated what still remain as the two main objections to each theory: (i) if reality is only like a B series then it is static and changeless and consequently atemporal, and (ii) reality cannot be like an A series because the A series harbours a contradiction. The debate about the argument, especially regarding the nature of the contradiction allegedly found in the A series, is characterised by a strange incommensurability of views. Proponents of the B-theory typically agree that McTaggart demonstrates a contradiction in the A series but fails to establish that the B series cannot contain change. Proponents of the A-theory fail to recognise any contradiction in the A series but agree that the B series is devoid of change. The fact that commentators have arrived at so many different and incommensurable interpretations of the argument has given rise to the idea that the argument is obscure and difficult. I will suggest that the source to the problem is the mistaken belief that McTaggart’s Paradox is a stand-alone argument that does not depend on any contentious ontological premises. As a result, commentators proceed to understand the argument on the basis of their own metaphysical assumptions, duly arriving at very different interpretations. As I will show, McTaggart himself explicitly claims that his argument depends on the ontological principles that form the basis of his idealist metaphysics, and which are established by a priori arguments. When those principles are made explicit, we arrive at an unambiguous reading of the argument and also understand the basis of the incommensurability of the dispute between A- and B-theorists. Interestingly, the principles guiding McTaggart’s reasoning are widely accepted in the philosophical community today. Indeed, they are what guide David Lewis’s reasoning in the problem of temporary intrinsics and lead him to postulate the reality of all possible worlds in a manner that bears close resemblance to the way McTaggart is led to the conclusion that time is unreal.

Sessão conjunta com o Seminário de pós-graduação em Filosofia Contemporânea da Faculdade de Letras da Universidade de Lisboa (FLUL).

17h00-18h30
António Zilhão (CFCUL/GI1)
Logótipo do evento, sobre fotografia dos Açores

An international symposium that convenes researchers specializing in various disciplines focused on the terrestrial and marine flora and vegetation of the Macaronesian region (Azores, Madeira, Selvagens, Canary Islands, and Cabo Verde).

Composição de imagens relativas à área das ciências forenses

O curso visa dotar os formandos com os conhecimento necessários à integração de equipas profissionais multidisciplinares nas áreas Médico-Legais e Forenses, em Laboratórios ou Serviços Médico-Legais e Forenses - candidaturas até 27 de julho.

Cientista a trabalhar com tubos de ensaio

Os participantes neste curso irão adquirir os conhecimentos essenciais à integração de equipas profissionais multidisciplinares na área das Análises Clínicas/Patologia Clínica, em laboratórios privados, públicos, hospitalares ou do Estado - candidaturas até 27 de julho.

Logótipo do evento

Physics Day é um evento promovido pelo Departamento de Física da Faculdade de Ciências da ULisboa, com um duplo objetivo: valorizar a diversidade e excelência da formação dos doutorados e promover um espaço de diálogo direto entre empresas e estudantes.

Gotas de água

O curso visa capacitar os formandos para a aplicação dos índices de qualidade ecológica utilizados na avaliação da qualidade ambiental em sistemas de transição, no âmbito da Diretiva Quadro da Água (DQA) - candidaturas até 31 de agosto.

Saída de campo (Geologia)

O curso, com candidaturas até 20 de julho, convida os professores do Ensino Básico e Secundário a explorar a Geologia a partir das rochas que afloram nas imediações da sua escola.

Composição de três imagens relativas à área da deteção remota

2.ª edição do curso, com candidaturas até 18 de outubro.

The conference aims to bring together key experts in the Medical Microwave Imaging (MMWI) field and will include invited talks, presentations and posters of peer-reviewed abstracts and conference papers, and workshops in satellite areas of research that are of interest to MMWI research.

Páginas